How much to give for Maggs?

[randomguymike]

Ok, I want the hometown guy, but which would you give up for him in a keeper?

I've got Javy for Maggs
or
M. Young for Maggs.

The only OF I'm keeping is Ichiro. I should be able to get Kendall in the first round of the filler draft. I have Guillen at SS. Javy for Maggs sounds better to me, because I don't see his numbers going up. Kendall won't be a huge drop off in Oakland, anyway. I'm leaning towards giving Javy.

[Druw4mvp]

of are more plentiful than a good catcher or ss/2b... id keep both of them...
id figure something else out for maggs...

[The Greatest Poster Alive]

Ok, I want the hometown guy, but which would you give up for him in a keeper?

I've got Javy for Maggs
or
M. Young for Maggs.

The only OF I'm keeping is Ichiro. I should be able to get Kendall in the first round of the filler draft. I have Guillen at SS. Javy for Maggs sounds better to me, because I don't see his numbers going up. Kendall won't be a huge drop off in Oakland, anyway. I'm leaning towards giving Javy.

I agree with TGO on this, Keep em both, and Work out a trade after your draft....